Grace Requires What? Disability care provider files federal court petition against NM health secretary

On the Sunday of Memorial Day weekend, at least one person in New Mexico was working: attorney Marina Cordova. On May 30, Cordova and her client, a care provider for people with developmental disabilities called

,

against New Mexico Department of Health Secretary

Alfredo Vigil

, Developmental Disabilities Supports Division Director

Mikki Rogers

, Gov.

Bill Richardson

, Attorney General

Gary King

and Human Services Department Secretary

Kathryn Falls

.

Why? GRU claims the DOH acted unconstitutionally by requiring certain

disability caregivers to pay back more than they made

when they wanted a break.

It's a complicated situation, but here's the bottom line:

Family living providers,

who are often parents or relatives of disabled people who have then trained to care for them at home,

make $2,150 a month.

(That money comes from Medicaid and is administered by the DOH.) If you consider in-home care a 24-hour job, then that breaks down to

$2.95 an hour.

But according to an October 2009 memo from Rogers that's included in the court documents,

those same caregivers have to pay $5 an hour back to the DOH when they want a break.

GRU, which provides both family living and "respite" (break-time) services, says that's unfair. What's more,

GRU alleges that the DOH made the $5 decision without public input or federal approval

—not to mention some studies to determine whether the amount was appropriate.

With family living providers entitled to hundreds of hours of respite each year, GRU, which is owned and operated by 108 family living providers, is worried that $5 an hour is too steep.

"Can you imagine all that money

they'll have to pay back?" Victor Duran, the president of GRU's board, says. "That's a lot of money."

Indeed, one of Cordova's points of argument is that going forward with a $5/hour reimbursement could all but bankrupt GRU. SFR is waiting from calls back from Cordova and the DOH, but we'll fill you in as soon as we know more.

Letters to the Editor

Mail letters to PO Box 4910 Santa Fe, NM 87502 or email them to editor[at]sfreporter.com. Letters (no more than 200 words) should refer to specific articles in the Reporter. Letters will be edited for space and clarity.

We also welcome you to follow SFR on social media (on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter) and comment there. You can also email specific staff members from our contact page.