State Denies Protest Of Common Core-aligned Testing Contract

Pearson will keep its contract with PARCC for now

New Mexico's purchasing agent has not found any problems with the way the state Public Education Department awarded a lucrative contract for a Common Core standardized test.

The agent issued an opinion Wednesday that a protest filed over the contract was without merit.

In May, the state Public Education Department awarded education conglomerate Pearson a contract to write and administer a new test for the Partnership for Assessment of Readiness for College and Careers. PARCC is a federally funded consortium of 14 states, including New Mexico, that have agreed to administer a test aligned with the Common Core State Standards Initiative. The new standardized test is designed to be taken entirely online and will take high school students roughly 10 hours to complete.

PARCC used New Mexico's education department as the purchasing agent for the contract, which is expected to affect between 6-10 million students enrolled in schools across the 14 states. In New Mexico, the PARCC test is scheduled to go into effect this coming school year.

The scope of the contract, which is estimated to bring Pearson more than $1 billion over an eight-year period (the contract is for four years but PARCC has the option to renew it for another four), brought controversy even before Pearson won it in May.

Last December, the Washington DC-based American Institute for Research filed a protest with the state purchasing agent arguing that the bid for the contract was written favorably for Pearson. Namely, AIR's takes issue with how the bid required the winner of the contract—whether it was Pearson or a different company—to use Pearson's online testing system for the first year of testing.

Such requirements were uncompetitive to other companies, AIR argued. Indeed, only Pearson responded to the request for proposal for the PARCC contract.

But both PED and Pearson wrote in filings to the state purchasing agent that AIR was only looking to break up the contract to benefit itself. Such actions, they argued, would cost taxpayers more money and delay the state's work in reforming education.

State Purchasing Agent Larry Maxwell sides with PED in his determination, arguing that the bid "was a careful and thoughtful decision and approach made for the benefit of the public."

"PED made a determination that their needs could be best met by procuring the services in the way in which they structured this RFP," Maxwell writes in the determination. "They determined this structure was the most practicable given the totality of the circumstances with which they had to deal."

AIR now has two options: drop their complaints completely or appeal the decision in Santa Fe's District Court. AIR Executive Vice President Jon Cohen tells SFR that his nonprofit doesn't want to see a Pearson monopoly over PARCC.

"We'd like to see more competition," AIR Executive Vice President Jon Cohen tells SFR. "We're going to circle our wagons and consider our options."

Read the State Purchasing Agent's determination below:

AIR Protest Determination by joeyjpeters

Letters to the Editor

Mail letters to PO Box 4910 Santa Fe, NM 87502 or email them to editor[at] Letters (no more than 200 words) should refer to specific articles in the Reporter. Letters will be edited for space and clarity.

We also welcome you to follow SFR on social media (on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter) and comment there. You can also email specific staff members from our contact page.