Aug. 16, 2017
Home / Articles / Cinema / Yay /  Give the Punters What They Want
Movie 2

Give the Punters What They Want

'Lucky Them' is funny, sad and surprisingly poignant

June 24, 2014, 12:00 am

So how is it that a movie with a familiar storyline (search for a disappeared musician), a lead character who’s a mess (Toni Collette as Ellie) and a second lead who’s a genuine goof (Thomas Haden Church as Charlie) is so engaging? Beats me. The magic of movies, perhaps? A wonderful performance by Collette as an embittered music critic? A knowing nod to Church’s strengths as a performer (Charlie mentions that he’s not deep, but he’s also not shallow)? A well-placed and underplayed movie star cameo? A delightful turn by stand-up comic Gary Gulman? The presence of Seattle as a character and not just a setting?

Lucky Them’s narrative is pretty simple: Ellie is told by her editor (Oliver Platt) that the magazine she writes for is struggling; she needs to find her ex-boyfriend, a beloved disappeared Seattle musician named Matthew Smith (Johnny Depp), and write a story about what he’s been doing for a decade. Naturally, the assignment is harder than it first seems, and Ellie would rather drink and fuck herself into a stupor than be vulnerable and introspective.

All the characters feel real (including Charlie), and the performances are pitch-perfect. Funny, sad, poignant, like a good song. Which real-life musician do you see as inspiration for Smith’s disappearance (I’m going with Richey Edwards)?



Directed by Megan Griffiths

With Collette, Church and Nina Arianda

CCA Cinematheque

97 min.


comments powered by Disqus
Fandango Logo


* indicates required
Choose your newsletter(s):

@SFReporter on Instagram